The Ultimate Debate

Which is better overall for security and training?

  1. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    I have a rottie and in my experience the rottie requires less training, though i do not think they are any better or worse than GSD for security. My dog is a pet first and security second. He will alert me at tje door when people come knocking, but while outside on the lawn he is rather quiet. He watches intently and absorbs info, feeling out the situation before acting, which I hear is what rotties normally do . Again, this is coming from a pet owner, not a person who trains for security. A rottie used and trained to guard may have a different response.

    As for training, rotties tend to be very self assured. They kind of just know what to do and arent reliant on signals from owners. Mine is very independant and does what it wants around the property but never goes off running, he knows the end of the border. They watch their owners alot and learn without commands. My rottie watched me enough times around the house that he learned to open doors independantly.

    Pic related, my pooch

  2. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    99% of dog breeds: 0 to 1 deaths a year, considered preventable accidents
    German shepherds: at least 1 death a year. 3rd most popular dog.
    Rottweilers: At least 2 deaths a year.
    Pitbulls: at least 30 deaths a year. Less than 20% of the dog population. Owners rarely saw the attack coming even in hindsight.
    >pitbull hate is irrational 30 people is a small price to pay who cares people die get over it

  3. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    >larping cat fag brings up pitbulls out of nowhere
    kys toxofreak

  4. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    Neither, because the science shows they are both actually more prone to aggression and attacks than a Pit but you only hear about Pits because cops are tarded and don’t know dog breeds.

    • 1 month ago
      Anonymous

      Lol no

      Pits show less outward aggression aka warnings. But they bite more often, without warning. I would rather have a snappy, snarling dog than a SHITbull that acts nice and then holds on to my bicep until it tears off.

      Literally every white gay with a SHITbull says they weren’t aggressive lmfao meanwhile their fucking nephew is dead

      • 1 month ago
        Anonymous

        Literally owned three throughout my life and never once had any even “close” calls as you spergs like to go on about. It is funny how quick you tools pick up on bullshit stories or “I heard once from a friend…” urban legends. Almost like you gravitate only to what you want to hear for some strange reason. You are worse than flat earthers to be honest.

        • 1 month ago
          Anonymous

          >i had 3 they never hurt anyone!
          300 dead kids is a big deal when if you lump everything that looks like a german shepherd together they cant even manage 1/3 of that

          Idgaf about your canine boyfriend i’m not taking the slightest chance for the sake of a damn dog known for attacking unexpectedly. Where i come from people got pitbulls as guard dogs because everyone knows what they’re capable of and one of those behind a fence is enough. All shitbulls must be exterminated. Only damn good thing cops do is shoot those worthless animals.

          • 1 month ago
            Anonymous

            >i had 3 pet tigers and they never hurt anyone stop being tigerphobic retard
            >i can’t believe you chuds would even think about murdering an innocent tiger just for enjoying his freedom
            >tigers are scientifically less aggressive than border collies and chihuahuas
            lol pitbull owners

            Triggered so much you have to pull out strawman arguments and copes so hard it would make a Black Lives Matter protestor blush…I can see this conversation is pretty one sided. Get fucked, dogs aren’t your enemy rational thought is.

            • 1 month ago
              Anonymous

              Rational thought. Human life is priceless. A pitbull is $50. Why should a human life be forced to take on the slightest amount of risk for the sake of a pitbull?

              You walk around with a button. You tell me half the people in the US pushed it last year and only 30 of them died from pushing it. I gain nothing for pushing the button. The button has no value. You paid $50 and are irrationally attached to it. I gain something for myself and my community if I destroy the button. The button is you expecting me to deal with your pitbull when my fellow brothers on 7th knew they were dangerous and kept them chained so only a robber would be pushing that button. Understand?

        • 1 month ago
          Anonymous

          >i had 3 pet tigers and they never hurt anyone stop being tigerphobic retard
          >i can’t believe you chuds would even think about murdering an innocent tiger just for enjoying his freedom
          >tigers are scientifically less aggressive than border collies and chihuahuas
          lol pitbull owners

          • 1 month ago
            Anonymous

            More like pit mommy = “my autistic schizoid white nationalist child with an AR15 is a model citizen. I have 3 and they’ve never shot up any schools.”

  5. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    German Shepherds because they have manic psycho energy
    I had rottweilers and they'd always pussy out if someone hopped into my backyard

    • 1 month ago
      Anonymous

      Sounds like you just don't know how to train them right or you got shit lineage

      • 1 month ago
        Anonymous

        He got the lineage that's appropriate for 99% of people. The other 1% are cops and soldiers. When some suburban fag has a dog that will kill any kid who climbs their fence when the dogs owner would go to jail if he did the same thing, that dog ends up drinking something sweet and green.

        • 1 month ago
          Anonymous

          Sounds like you just don't know how to train them right or you got shit lineage

          German Shepherds because they have manic psycho energy
          I had rottweilers and they'd always pussy out if someone hopped into my backyard

          Most dogs are just dogs. it takes a very specific line of purpose bred dog to actually be willing (and able) to attack and continue attacking a person. you can scream down most trained police dogs no problem. you just have to know it and do it and most people do not. your inate fear plays into their "ability".

  6. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    both are built for BBC

    • 1 month ago
      Anonymous

      Big Border Cock

  7. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    Your hired gun for security should be human so they dont kill your kids friends or your neighbors son for daring to look for his frisbee.

    Aggressive dogs shouldn’t exist

  8. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    I've encountered both irl. Had good experiences with both, although the rotts I've met have been sweeter than the GSDs. Not that the GSDs were hostile, they were just more alert and seemed more protective. The rotts were big babies. That's all anecdotal though so it's worth fuckall, although I'd imagine a rott might require slightly less training.

    • 1 month ago
      Anonymous

      GSDs are very sweet, but only with their owners. They don't take much interest to people outside of their families; they're kinda like Shibes in that way. For that reason -- their "outsider distrust" -- I consider them the superior guard dog.

  9. 1 month ago
    Anonymous

    It just hit me that I have never seen a rottweiler in real life.

    • 1 month ago
      Anonymous

      Rotts are fucking hideous in real life. Meme about pit bulls all you like but my god rotts are ugly as fuck.

    • 1 month ago
      Anonymous

      My mother was attacked by a Rottweiler, ripped her jacket but otherwise she was fine.

Your email address will not be published.